Really, Parenthood You HAD To Go The Older Child, Latent With Attachment Issue Possibilities, Route? Really?!?!

I watched Parenthood last night with a bit of unease. I have watched it that way most of this season. I was sure that they were going to go with the adoptive parents take the baby home and birthmother returns to take the baby back JUST before her legal right to do so has ended. Seeing as how last night was the season finale that put a monkey wrench in my concept. Which meant I really did not know what to think. Michael thought that Julie and Joel would get the baby. I knew they wouldn't. 

I am glad they did not go with the storyline I expected. What do I think of what they did? Well, obviously, Zoe had the right to her baby. Obviously, it is sad for Julia and Joel. It was done okay, I guess. It's kind of old, as storylines go. Jenna wrote a great post about it (I've been kind of waiting to see what she said - I respect her a lot!)

And then there is the continued adoption storyline. OMG!!! I was SO NOT prepared for that boy to get out of the car. Michael was dealing with some last minute work disasters that kept him from watching with me. So, I was alone, on my bed and I was physically cringing from that child. Now, admittedly, if that boy came from his mother, who has cared for him and cared for him well he should not have true attachment problems. He should have adjustment problems. He should be angry. He should be sort of Problem Child like (you have seen that movie, right?). 

That said I am worried about where that storyline is going to go. I am worried that will go down the road of attachment. I know that people tend to see what they live. I know that I see possible attachment issues in places I never would have before. A friend recently told me about a relative adopting a toddler who had been the NICU for the first several months of their lives. My first impulse was to say tell the mom to read Taming the Tiger While It's Still a Kitten. Afterward I wondered if I should have just said congratulations. I wish I had known things before but I don't know if anyone could have made me see. But the point is I see attachment things all the time now that I did not see before. 

That said, I have seen RAD and other attachment disorders in the news more and there are more moms talking about it on facebook and in other places. Plus, I actually have seen two TV shows in the last few months that have done episodes where there is a character with RAD. So, it won't shock me if they go there. And I don't know if I will be able to watch it. Maybe I will. Probably not without Hubby. It would be highly emotional to watch. 

Then immediately my mind goes to what will Julia and Joel do? Will they keep this boy who comes in and causes trouble? Will they hand him off? That is a fair question regardless of if the show goes the attachment route or the simply troubled because mom is all of a sudden gone route. Oh goodness. I am so not prepared for that. The idea of watching them make that decision, of hearing it said through the mouths of writers I am 99% sure have no idea what that feels like. Oh what a mess. 

One last point - the jump from wanting a baby to agreeing to adopt a nine year old boy (or however old he is) feels very forced. They never say they are open to adopting an older child. Earlier in the episode they say "we just want a baby." As viewers we never even see them discuss it. All of which means they go into this with no idea what it means. No thought. Again, what a mess. 

6 Comments:

  1. My DVR just finished playing the episode from last night. With that said, I am still digesting everything, but I lost a lot of respect for the show in recent weeks. A lot of far fetched (even for Hollywood) things have happened. I think the item that bothered me the most at this point was what you mentioned with Julia and Joel never saying anything about being open to adopting older children. That is very different than a baby and I can not imagine that something like that would ever happen - especially a car dropping off just like that. Just thinking about this makes my skin crawl.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yeah, I don't really know enough about the foster system to know what happens. Although, they never spoke about fostering. Which is different then adoption. They are different people, different processes, etc. Way too convenient - even for Hollywood.

      Delete
  2. It was a different ending then I expected. I love the show & the characters - but I connected when they dealt with Autism. Although that is not our diagnosis - I felt so close to Christina - when she went to that meeting & verbalized it.. oh the tears & as sad as it was there was comfort. Our family can never understand what we have been thru or face.. they love us, they love him, they try but they have not gone thru it - they can't feel what I feel, what we feel. Sitting in a room of strangers who can relate to where you are at this very moment can be more loving then sitting in a room with the family that raised you, loves you & knows you - its weird but true. I personally felt like the writers did such an amazing job with that aspect of the show I fell even more in love with it. I feel like obviously one or more of the writers HAS to have gone thru or are going thru a similar situation as we are. That being said I am horrified with the cheating parts - just wish for once they could leave that out of a show :( I pray they handle the adoption issues wisely & respectfully. It is such an emotional show for me - I laugh & I cry while watching it! :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I know!! I am so sick of all the infidelity on TV. I don't know why shows always think that is a good storyline. Grrr!!!

      Delete
  3. My husband and I bawled when the child (looked more like age 5 to me) came out of the car. The show said the mother signed away her rights to avoid fostercare. This means that Julia and Joel are planning to adopt the child. The bio mom is incarcerated, no reason to believe he will have RAD. We know nothing to assume anything but his mother loved and cared for him. My toddler does not have RAD. She went from anxious attachment in the early days to secure attachment no different than if I had her from birth. Not all kids who are adopted older have RAD. They could do wonderful things with this story line to educate just as they did with Max.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. They could do a gerat job. I know that not all older child adoptions have RAD but some do. My daughter was only seven months when she came home and she does. We know nothing of how this child was cared for. They could go with a storyline that has him coming from a loving home where he was well cared for - or they could not. Either way could serve to educate and be done well just like they did with Max. Although, I'm not sure someone who has not lived with RAD can accurately portray it - but then again good writers research what they plan to write about so maybe they would do it well. For me, living in the thick of a toddler with RAD I have to say I am a little anxious about what they will do. I guess we will find out in the fall.

      Delete

Thanks for your kind words! I love hearing from you.