I have put off blogging this event for a week because I am afraid of how what I say will come off. I do not wish to insult anyone. I want my outrage at this to be clear while still managing not to convey the wrong thoughts or feelings. Or perpetrating some common myths. However, I DO want people to know that what this woman did to me was unacceptable. Not that she did it to ME but that she did it to ANYONE. So, here goes...Last weekend we attended Irish Fest. It takes place downtown and we love it. We go every year. There is music and lots of local pubs come out and you can buy some traditional Irish food. A lot of local Irish dance schools come out and perform. There are a bunch of kids things to do during the day - coloring, face painting, a juggler a balloon artist. It is just fun! Plus, we love the music so we stay and dance until the last band is done. We do this both Friday and Saturday.
Saturday night, shortly before the last band went on stage a lady approached me when Hubby took Big Brother and Big Sister to go get some ice cream for everyone. She walks up and makes a comment about how I have "a bunch of kids." This comment being in the "Boy you have your hands full" tone I immediately am on the defensive. "I have four," I said. To which she responds, "Does money ever get tight for you?" I look at her somewhat dumbfounded and in my head I am trying to figure out what it is that makes us look like we are in SUCH financial need that it is not insane for a stranger to come up and ask us this. I am guessing that it is because the kids all have short sleeves or sleeveless dresses. The day had been really warm but the evening was cool. But that is beside the point.
When I did not really answer her, I sort of shrugged, she said, "Because I am wondering if you might consider giving up the baby for adoption." And now I am stunned. STUNNED!!! I am more or less speechless. I must have glanced at Little Sister because the lady looks at her and says, "Oh did you adopt her?" "Yes," I say. She shouts to her friend to come on over and look at Tiny Sister. I turn my body around and refuse to look at her or speak to her anymore. I am so mad about this. I am so totally freaked out about this. I tell Hubby who turns around and said, "She wants to sell our baby."
Now, please understand I am not in any way saying that I am "too good" to place my child for adoption. I am not saying that I am better than a mom who chooses adoption for her child. Not. At. ALL. It is not about that. And now we get into the part that I am nervous about writing. See what she did was terrible! No matter who I am. It is inappropriate to ask a woman to give up their child. Period. End of conversation.
Obviously, I am grateful that Big Brother and Little Sister were placed for adoption. And I have no idea how that happened. But what that woman did - to walk up to a woman, regardless if she has a baby, a young child or is pregnant, and ask for their baby is inappropriate. Placing a child for adoption is NOT inappropriate but only the parents of that child can decide if adoption is the choice for them. And no one, not the families of that man and woman, or their friends, or any adoption professional they may have talked to or a stranger or anyone else should ever make a woman feel like they "should" or they "have to" place their child.
Also, people need to stop making assumptions about the "type of woman" who "gives up" their child. Just because a woman is young or does not have a lot of money or is single or is still in school or has placed a child before or has several other young children does not mean you should approach her about adoption. When someone you know does decide to place a child for adoption she deserves your support. She deserves your comfort. She deserves you to stand by her when the days are rough. She deserves you to be excited and happy for her when things are good. When someone you know decides to parent their baby she deserves your support. She deserves your comfort. She deserves you to stand by her when the days are rough, She deserves you to be excited and happy for her when things are good.
wow.... you are absolutely right- that is beyond inappropriate!! What a horrible experience for you :(
ReplyDeleteI'm thinking she must have been out of her mind, or desperate. Which is worse? I don't know.
ReplyDeletePlease say hello to my new friend...she makes Grace and I smile when we think about her. =)btw, I LOVE this photo!
when I say "desperate" what I meant was maybe she or someone she REALLY cares about can not have children and somehow, she thought this was the way to go about getting a baby. Out of desperation. I don't know really, I'm just trying to see this from some other point of view. I'm sorry.
ReplyDeleteOH MY LORD... You are such a wonderful, patient & loving mama... there just might have been a not-so-flattering article about ME in the paper the next day if I had experienced that same situation!
ReplyDeleteI hope this woman was simply drunk and not serious. What a MORON! You were much more gracious about the situation than I would have been!
ReplyDeleteWell said. There is nothing that could justify her asking that question of someone. No amount of desperation. NOTHING.
ReplyDeleteI really hope this is the only time she's ever done this, although I fear it isn't. What is wrong with some people?
I am reading this with my mouth gaping open. Seriously???
ReplyDeleteAnd, you're right, it's completely unacceptable to ask ANY mom (no matter what part of the world you're in) to hand over their child. I am so sorry that this happened to you. You handled it with much more grace than I probably could have-I struggle terribly with the situations when people come up to me and say, "I'd like one of those (our Ethiopian daughter)." It's just so rude, as though my child is a commodity.
Thanks for sharing this-it truly blow my mind.
So what I am getting from this is that no mother should ever be asked to give up her child. Well that would be such a nice concept but I as a mother 21 yrs of age was begged in public to give my child to a couple from your area and they thought they had every right to do so because they were unable to have children. They sat at a table in a resurant and asked me what the father was like and just knew my baby would have curly hair and just knew God had sent them to me and how they would be so good for him because they could do so much better than me. This was in 1991. 20 years later I look at my wonderful son and know without a doubt NO ONE could have EVER given him anything BETTER than his own mother. And that is exactly what I gave him!!!! I was and am poor but I gave him so mich better that a roof over his head! I gave him all of my love by not lettign ppl like YOU bully me!!!!
ReplyDeleteGood grief! Completely inappropriate & I would've not handled it as nicely as you did! Sorry you had to go through this mama.
ReplyDeleteAnonymous,
ReplyDeleteI am sorry that happened to you. I am not sure how you found yourself to be at a restaurant with these people. Or why you were discussing with them whether or not they should parent your child. They had no right to ask you to give them your baby. That is what I said. And I am sort of unsure as to how I am at fault here.
That is absolutely and totally wrong on so many levels. I am not sure where that person's head was but clearly not on straight. I want to adopt but I would never ever go up to someone and ask them about adopting their child. Like others, I would not have handled that as well as you did.
ReplyDeleteAs unbelieveable as it sounds - this sort of thing is more common than you think. I believe people are just getting more bold about their desire and efforts to take another woman's baby. When I was a teenager and pregnant, the Obstitrian I sought medical care from convinced my parents and myself to go along with his plans of having my baby adopted by his "friends" )another doctor and his wife - when I went into labor he put me under and then took my daughter the second she was born -I never held her or saw her. I grieve this more than 30 years later. Hope you guys don't mind my venting!
ReplyDeleteTerrible! and poor anonymous, this should never happen. This is really really relevant to a blog post I wrote today. :(
ReplyDelete